|   |   | 
 
| # Reg. Voters | Poll Book | % Reg. Voters | Nancy E. Gallagher | Stewart D. McDonald | |
| TOTAL | -- | -- | -- | 7808 | 8238 | 
| City of Alma #1 | 1832 | 1205 | 65.78% | 533 | 494 | 
| City of Alma #2 | 1941 | 857 | 44.15% | 418 | 383 | 
| City of Alma #4 | 2288 | 1094 | 47.81% | 551 | 465 | 
| AVCB | -- | 870 | N/A | 376 | 368 | 
| City of Ithaca | 2003 | 1422 | 70.99% | 634 | 694 | 
| City of St. Louis #1 | 925 | 606 | 65.51% | 309 | 259 | 
| City of St. Louis #2 | 1490 | 930 | 62.42% | 443 | 402 | 
| Arcada #1A | 1334 | 879 | 65.89% | 342 | 491 | 
| Bethany #1A | 1030 | 679 | 65.92% | 257 | 368 | 
| Elba #1A | 538 | 371 | 68.96% | 180 | 135 | 
| Elba #2 | 399 | 289 | 72.43% | 149 | 88 | 
| Emerson #1A | 691 | 479 | 69.32% | 167 | 272 | 
| Fulton #1A | 1819 | 1272 | 69.93% | 613 | 455 | 
| Hamilton | 332 | 208 | 62.65% | 89 | 92 | 
| Lafayette #1A | 449 | 320 | 71.27% | 137 | 149 | 
| Newark | 641 | 433 | 67.55% | 168 | 233 | 
| New Haven | 717 | 463 | 64.57% | 182 | 233 | 
| North Shade | 409 | 287 | 70.17% | 121 | 117 | 
| North Star | 641 | 468 | 73.01% | 191 | 230 | 
| Pine River #1A | 1712 | 1154 | 67.41% | 456 | 572 | 
| Seville | 1573 | 1026 | 65.23% | 394 | 533 | 
| Sumner #1A | 1347 | 859 | 63.77% | 365 | 413 | 
| Washington | 639 | 457 | 71.52% | 201 | 182 | 
| Wheeler | 1849 | 1283 | 69.39% | 532 | 610 | 
| Nancy E. Gallagher | Stewart D. McDonald |